Simple Tips To Resell Successfully on eBay, Poshmark, Mercari

Starting a resale business across multiple marketplaces like eBay, Poshmark, and Mercari can be a lucrative venture if you approach it strategically. Jade and Chris, a reselling duo couple, recently shared their journey after three months of selling, generating $9,145.30 in 90 days. Here are their key tips to help you succeed in the resale market, whether you're a beginner or looking to scale up on these platforms.

1. Optimize your listings

Require immediate payment: This simple step helps avoid issues with non-paying buyers, ensuring smoother transactions across all platforms.
Craft compelling titles: Start your title with the brand name (e.g., "Zara" or "Vintage/Rare") and avoid redundant terms like "New," as it’s already indicated under item specifics on eBay and Mercari, or in tags on Poshmark.
Refresh old listings: If you don’t have anything new to list, end a few of your oldest listings and relist them with updated information or pricing to keep your store active on each marketplace.
Set a personal listing goal: Start small—Jade and Chris began with six listings per day and now aim for 15-20, depending on inventory. This consistency builds momentum across platforms.

2. Boost sales with smart strategies

Use promotions wisely: On eBay, keep promoted listing fees low (2-5%), with Jade and Chris recommending never exceeding 2%. On Poshmark, share your listings frequently to boost visibility, and on Mercari, use the "Promote" feature sparingly to maximize profit.
Leverage auctions on eBay: Auction highly sought-after items with 5-7 day durations, ending on weekends for optimal performance. On Poshmark and Mercari, consider "Offer to Likers" to attract buyers.
Send offers: If you have margin, send offers to interested buyers to close sales faster—available on all three platforms.
Respond promptly: Reply to messages ASAP—ideally the same day. Quick responses often lead to more sales, especially on Poshmark, where buyer engagement is key.

3. Monitor and adjust pricing

Check sell-through rate (STR): STR is everything. To calculate, divide the number of sold listings by the total active listings for that item on each platform and multiply by 100. A 90-100% STR means the item will likely sell within a day or two, while below 20% could take months (or longer). Adjust pricing accordingly.
Research price comps: Look at recent sales and higher-priced items on all platforms, as prices fluctuate daily. For newcomers, pricing slightly lower ($1-3) can move items faster and build reviews, especially on Mercari, where competition can be fierce.

4. Source and scale inventory

Diversify sourcing: Jade and Chris source from Whatnot, Goodwill, thrift stores, estate sales, local clearance sales, and Facebook Marketplace. This variety keeps their 620 active listings ($26K total) fresh across eBay, Poshmark, and Mercari.
Aim for high profit margins: Comp everything before listing and target 350-600% profit margins—e.g., $18-22 on a $5 item or $120 on a $20 item.
Build gradually: Start with 20-25 listings per day (Jade and Chris’s current goal) and scale as you gain confidence across the platforms.

5. Enhance the customer experience

Packaging matters: A small touch goes a long way. Include a packing slip, a sticker, and a handwritten thank-you note to delight buyers, which can lead to better reviews on Poshmark and Mercari, and higher feedback scores on eBay.
Build feedback: Purchase from other sellers on each platform to build up your own positive feedback, establishing credibility across marketplaces.

Real results from real effort

Jade and Chris’s journey is inspiring. They made their first three sales within 48 hours of listing and grew from selling one item every two days to 4-6 items per day—all while working about an hour a day (not including sourcing) from two different states. With 180 items sold and a clear strategy, their success proves that consistency and smart practices pay off when selling on eBay, Poshmark, and Mercari.

Get started today!

Ready to turn your resale dreams into reality? These tips can set you on the path to profitability across multiple marketplaces, but you don’t have to navigate it alone. Take the next step and get started with Reeva—your partner in building a successful resale business.

Get started